Binance vs Smartbroker+ Comparison
In our overall rating Smartbroker+ leads with 4.4 out of 5 points, ahead of Binance with 2.2. On disclosed fees Binance is cheaper: € 1.00 instead of € 9.00 per €1,000 purchase. If you care most about stability and support, Smartbroker+ has the better sub-scores. Binance lists more cryptocurrencies (482) than Smartbroker+ (39).
| 0.1% spot, up to 2% instant buy | Fees | 0.9 % |
| € 1.00 | Minimum cost per €1,000 | € 9.00 |
| 482 | Cryptos | 39 |
| SEPA Transfer, Credit Card | Payment Methods | SEPA Transfer |
| License in Germany refused by BaFin | Regulation | Crypto custodian Tangany GmbH has a BaFin license |
Cost comparison
The basis is a Bitcoin purchase worth €1,000, calculated from the disclosed trading fee. A price markup in the spread is not included, because most providers do not publish it.
| € 1.00 | Minimum cost per €1,000 | € 9.00 |
| 0.1% spot, up to 2% instant buy | Fees | 0.9 % |
| € 1.37 | Wallet transfer | – |
| Limited | Cost transparency | Limited |
| ~$10 USD | Minimum Amount | € 0.01 |
| SEPA Transfer, Credit Card | Payment Methods | SEPA Transfer |
On disclosed fees you pay €8.00 less at Binance per €1,000 purchase.
Binance separates order book trading from direct purchases: regular users pay 0.1% on spot trades, while buying by card or wallet payment costs 2%.
| Transaction | Cost at Binance |
|---|---|
| Spot trading, regular user | 0.1% maker, 0.1% taker |
| Spot trading paying fees in BNB | 0.075% maker and taker (25% discount) |
| Direct buy and sell by card, Apple Pay or Google Pay | 2% |
| Direct buy and sell via PayPal | 1.5% |
| Direct buy via Revolut | 1.1% |
| Buy and sell via SEPA | EUR 1 |
| Crypto withdrawals | network fee per coin |
How to save: Going through the order book pays off: EUR 1,000 costs EUR 1 in spot trading fees, but EUR 20 by card. Paying fees in BNB saves another 25%. See how Binance compares with MiCA-licensed providers in our crypto exchange comparison.
Fees as of 21 October 2026 according to the Binance fee overview.
For crypto trades, Smartbroker+ charges a 0.90% mark-up when buying and a 0.90% mark-down when selling on the trading venue's price. The quoted price also contains the trading venue's own margin. Trading runs around the clock against euros, via market order.
| Transaction | Cost at Smartbroker+ |
|---|---|
| Buying or selling a cryptocurrency | 0.90% of the trade value plus the trading venue's mark-up or mark-down |
| Order under €500 | an extra €1 small-order surcharge |
| Order size | from €0.01 to €100,000 per order |
| Securities account and crypto wallet | free, no system fee |
| Savings plan on one of 35 crypto ETPs | no order fee, plus customary spreads and product costs |
| Deposit by SEPA direct debit | up to €5,000 per deposit and €12,000 per month, funds tradable within seconds |
How to save: From an order volume of €500, the small-order surcharge no longer applies. On a €100 order it amounts to 1%, so together with the 0.90% you pay 1.90% plus the trading venue's mark-up. If you want to invest regularly, a savings plan on a crypto ETP runs without an order fee; you then hold a security rather than your own coins.
As of 1 November 2026 according to the Smartbroker+ conditions page and its crypto price and service schedule.
Pros & Cons
- 482 cryptocurrencies tradable, the widest selection among established exchanges (measured on 3 September 2026 via Binance's public API)
- Spot trading from 0.1% maker and taker, 0.075% with BNB
- Largest crypto exchange worldwide by trading volume, deep liquidity
- Proof of reserves with zk-SNARKs, latest coverage at least 100% for BTC, ETH, USDT and BNB (1 October 2026)
- Futures, staking and savings plans in the international offering
- No MiCA licence: restrictions in the EU depending on country and account status; Binance withdrew its Greek application on 24 June 2026
- Only 29 of the 482 coins trade directly against the euro. Everything else goes through another currency, usually a stablecoin, which adds cost and exchange rate risk.
- Direct purchases by card cost 2%
- Guilty plea in the US in 2023 with a $4.3 billion penalty
- Attack on the hot wallets on 29 October 2026, withdrawals suspended from 30 October to 1 November
- 39 cryptocurrencies tradable alongside stocks, ETFs, and derivatives
- Savings plans on 35 crypto ETPs with no order fee, plus more than 10,800 savings plans on stocks, ETFs and funds
- Crypto custodian Tangany GmbH, authorised by BaFin under MiCAR since August 2025
- Minimum investment possible from just 0.01 €
- App available for iOS, Android, and web use
- Deposits by SEPA direct debit can be traded within seconds
- No transfers to or from your own wallets: crypto can only be bought and sold within Smartbroker+
- No staking for directly held cryptocurrencies
- On top of the 0.90%, the trading venue's mark-up or mark-down applies, plus a €1 small-order surcharge on orders under €500
- Crypto wallet requires residence in Germany, and trading is only against euros via market order
- Waiting time after registration until first trade is occasionally criticized
Score Comparison
User Experiences
AI AnalysisAccording to reviews, Binance is often praised overall for its ease of use, the large selection of coins, and fees that are generally perceived as low. At the same time, users occasionally report criticism regarding support, verification, and language options, especially with regard to a German app version.
According to reviews, Smartbroker+ is generally often described as clear and easy to understand. Users particularly appreciate the simple app experience as well as low fees and conditions, while support-related topics and individual technical points are perceived by some users as having room for improvement.
This analysis is based on 1002 user reviews evaluated by AI from the Apple App Store and Google Play Store. The total number of reviews on the respective platforms may be higher, the platform ratings (star ratings) shown refer to all reviews available there. The reviews shown reflect user experiences and do not represent the site operator’s own assessment. All information is provided without guarantee. As of: March 2026. This comparison does not constitute investment advice.
Features
| available | Savings plan | available |
| available | Staking | not available |
| available | Wallet transfer | not available |
| not available | Cost transparency | not specified |
| available | 2FA security | not specified |
| available | Whitelist | not specified |
| available | SEPA transfer | available |
| available | Credit card | not available |
| not available | Minimum amount | not specified |
| available | Mobile app (iOS/Android) | available |
| not specified | BaFin-regulated custodian | available |
| not specified | Web platform | available |
| not specified | Stocks & ETFs | available |
- Largest crypto exchange worldwide by trading volume
- Spot from 0.1%, 0.075% with BNB
- Proof of reserves with zk-SNARKs
- On the market since 2017
- No MiCA authorisation, no entry in the ESMA register
- Neobroker with stocks, ETFs, derivatives, and crypto on one platform
- BaFin-licensed crypto custodian Tangany GmbH
- Crypto purchases from €0.01, crypto ETP savings plans with no order fee
- Trading fees of 0.9 % for crypto
The five areas head to head
AI AnalysisFees & Costs
Users often cite Binance’s fees as a positive point and frequently describe them as low compared with other providers. At the same time, some reviews perceive the fees as too high. Overall, user data suggests a predominantly positive view of the fees.
According to reviews, Smartbroker+ fees are often viewed positively. Users particularly appreciate the low fees and conditions, which are generally perceived as inexpensive. Overall, the pricing data gives a largely positive impression.
Usability & User Experience
According to reviews, users particularly appreciate the intuitive app and ease of use at Binance, which appeals to both beginners and more experienced users. However, the interface is occasionally described as confusing or too complicated. Many users also want a German language option to make everyday use even more convenient.
Users particularly appreciate the clear and intuitive operation of the Smartbroker+ app. According to reviews, the application is often perceived as easy to use, which makes getting started easier. However, some users also report that the interface can be confusing, so this area is described in individual cases as having room for improvement.
Features & Offering
According to reviews, users mainly praise the large selection of coins. Users also report that Binance is suitable for beginners and appears easy to use. Occasionally, users would like additional language options as well as an iPad app to better adapt the offering to their usage.
Some users would like additional convenience features such as direct debit for savings plans, instant or real-time transfers, and notes for the watchlist. According to reviews, the newsletter is also occasionally perceived as rather limited.
Stability & Security
According to reviews, Binance is perceived by many users as reliable. Overall, the opinion on stability and reliability is predominantly positive.
Regarding stability and reliability, users occasionally report technical issues or longer loading times. Overall, the available reviews in this area do not point to a clearly positive or negative picture.
Customer Support
User data paints a rather critical picture of support: users report a lack of support. Verification is also described as time-consuming in some reviews. In addition, users would like better assistance with account-related issues and withdrawals.
When it comes to support, users in the reviews report mixed experiences comparatively often. In some cases, poor customer service, unanswered email requests, or a lack of support are mentioned, which is why this area is considered to have room for improvement from the users' perspective.
Details
| Binance Holdings Ltd. | Company | Smartbroker AG |
| 2017 | Founded | 2019 |
| License in Germany refused by BaFin | Regulation | Crypto custodian Tangany GmbH has a BaFin license |
| ~$10 USD | Minimum Amount | € 0.01 |
| Photo ID | KYC | eID, Video-ID, PostIdent |
Verdict
In our overall rating Smartbroker+ leads with 4.4 against 2.2 for Binance.
On disclosed fees you pay €8.00 less at Binance per €1,000 purchase.
For most investors Smartbroker+ is therefore the better choice.
Editorial assessment, November 2026: We have downgraded Binance to 2.2 out of 5 and do not recommend the exchange. The deciding factor is the missing authorisation: no Binance company is listed in ESMA's register of crypto-asset service providers authorised under MiCA (file dated 5 November 2026, accessed 8 November 2026), and Binance withdrew its application in Greece on 24 June 2026. On top of that came the attack on the exchange's hot wallets on 29 October 2026, after which withdrawals were suspended from 30 October to 1 November. Low trading fees and the large choice of coins do not outweigh this for us. MiCA-licensed exchanges are listed in our comparison of regulated crypto exchanges.
In short: Binance is the world's largest crypto exchange by trading volume: more than 480 coins, spot trading from 0.1%, from 0.075% with BNB, plus futures and a regular proof of reserves. For investors in the EU, licensing comes first: Binance holds no MiCA licence, and according to Binance users in the EU may be restricted depending on their country and account status. According to Binance, balances remain accessible and can be withdrawn.
Is Binance safe and licensed in the EU?
Binance is not taking new customers in the EU at the moment. Crypto exchanges need a licence under the EU's MiCA regulation to serve customers in the EU. The transition period for providers registered under national rules ended on 1 July 2026 across the EU, and on 31 December 2025 in Germany. Binance does not appear in the ESMA register (file of 22 October 2026, 387 licensed providers). Binance withdrew its application with the Greek capital market regulator on 24 June 2026 and announced that it would apply in another EU member state. Background in our report on the Binance MiCA licence.
Reserves and track record: Binance regularly publishes a proof of reserves, verified with a Merkle tree and zk-SNARKs. The snapshot of 1 October 2026 shows coverage of 100.35% for Bitcoin, 100.00% for Ether, 103.88% for USDT and 100.47% for BNB (Binance proof of reserves). For emergencies such as hacks, Binance keeps its SAFU fund. In 2023 Binance pleaded guilty in the US to breaching anti-money laundering rules and paid $4.3 billion.
Hack in October 2026: On the evening of 29 October 2026 an attacker drained crypto from Binance wallets. In an official announcement the exchange puts the damage at around $6.3 billion, of which about $3 billion is frozen on-chain. According to Binance the entry point was an employee's compromised laptop; no private key leak has been found. Binance will cover all losses from its SAFU fund and company funds; according to Recovery Update #4 of 1 November, around 95 percent had been replaced. Since the morning of 1 November the first withdrawals have been running again; at 16:30 UTC the Binance interface showed them open for Bitcoin, Ether, BNB, Solana, XRP, USDT and USDC. Binance expects to publish its full proof of reserves by Tuesday, 3 November (UTC). What happened is in our report on the Binance hack, where the money went in our on-chain analysis. If you want to hold your coins independently of any exchange, our hardware wallet comparison lists the devices.
What you can do yourself: if you still hold funds at Binance, turn on two-factor authentication and a withdrawal address whitelist, and keep larger amounts in your own wallet, for example a hardware wallet, or move them to an exchange with a MiCA licence.
Who is Binance for?
Binance suits experienced traders outside the EU who want a very large choice of coins, futures and low spot fees. If you want to open an account in the EU, choose an exchange with a MiCA licence, such as OKX, Kraken, Bybit EU or Bitvavo. Our report on Binance fees breaks down the costs; all licensed providers are listed in our comparison of regulated crypto exchanges.
Smartbroker+ is perceived in the DACH region as a multi-asset broker that combines cryptocurrencies with stocks, ETFs, and derivatives on one platform. With 39 tradable cryptocurrencies and custody via Tangany GmbH, which has held a MiCAR authorisation from BaFin since August 2025, the provider is considered to be on solid regulatory footing. Smartbroker AG has notified BaFin under MiCAR that it receives and transmits crypto orders, which are executed via Baader Bank. Trading fees of 0.9 % for crypto are in the mid-range among German neobrokers; the trading venue's mark-up or mark-down and a €1 small-order surcharge below €500 come on top.
Users appreciate that crypto can be bought from as little as €0.01, which enables an especially accessible entry point. Regular investing works through savings plans on 35 crypto ETPs, which run without an order fee. The platform is available via app and web and is aimed at investors who want to manage different asset classes centrally. For users who already invest in stocks and ETFs and want to add crypto as an additional component, Smartbroker+ is seen as a practical solution.
Transfers to or from personal wallets are not possible, and staking is not offered for directly held cryptocurrencies; both are occasionally criticized by users. Deposits come only from the registered reference account, either by SEPA direct debit with funds available within seconds or by bank transfer. Users see room for improvement in the waiting time after registration, and the crypto wallet requires residence in Germany. Smartbroker+ is therefore particularly suitable for securities investors in the DACH region looking for a German broker with BaFin-regulated crypto custody and a broad product range.