The information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Cryptocurrency investments carry a high degree of risk. Always conduct your own research.

MEV exploit worth $25 million: US judge acquits the Peraire-Bueno brothers

A federal court in New York acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on November 16, 2026, in the $25 million MEV exploit case. What lies behind the ruling and how you can protect your own swaps from sandwich bots.

Empty courtroom at night with dark wood panelling, the Ethereum symbol glowing above the judge’s bench
A US federal court in Manhattan has acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers in the MEV case.
7 min read
Share:
Categories: Hacks & Security

Key points

  • Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges in New York on November 16, 2026.
  • Prosecutors had accused the brothers of using a flaw in the MEV-Boost software in April 2023 to take about $25 million from sandwich bots.
  • In the judge's view, the government failed to prove a false statement, which a wire fraud conviction requires.

The best-known criminal case over MEV on Ethereum has ended without a conviction. A federal court in Manhattan acquitted the two MIT-trained brothers, Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, on Monday, November 16, 2026. Judge Jessica Clarke granted the defence motion for acquittal and thereby threw out the charges of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. There will be no second trial.

For users of decentralised exchanges, the case is more than a court note. It revolves around the very bots that profit from other people's swaps every day. The ruling, however, only establishes that this conduct was not punishable as wire fraud under US law. Whether it was fair, the court expressly left open.

MEV trial acquittal: why Judge Clarke found no fraud

Under US federal law, wire fraud requires that someone deceives by means of a material false statement. That is precisely the point Clarke did not consider proven. The prosecution had not shown that the brothers made false promises in their transactions, Cointelegraph reports. Prosecutors had argued that the brothers, acting as validators, broke a kind of commitment to honest behaviour. A validator is a computer that proposes blocks on Ethereum and stakes ether as collateral to do so.

Bar chart: 24-hour price change of the ten largest crypto assets
The ten largest crypto assets excluding stablecoins, price change over the past 24 hours in percent. Source: CoinMarketCap, as of November 19, 2026, 8:53 pm CET

Clarke countered that the prosecution's arguments ignored evidence about the Ethereum ecosystem and the technical meaning of a commitment. That is how the magazine Gizmodo quotes the decision, citing the news agency Reuters. The judge also made clear what she was not deciding:

“The question before the court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral.”

Jessica Clarke, judge at the US District Court in Manhattan, decision of November 16, 2026, as quoted by Reuters (source)

Nor did the court examine whether the conduct might have violated other laws that were not charged. The decision is therefore no free pass, but a rejection of one particular theory of the case.

MEV-Boost and sandwich bots: what happened on Ethereum in April 2023

MEV stands for maximal extractable value. It refers to the profit that can be made by deciding the order and selection of transactions in a block. A sandwich bot is a program that spots a large buy order in the blockchain's waiting area, buys just before it and sells at a higher price right after. The actual buyer pays a worse price, and the difference goes to the bot.

MEV-Boost is add-on software through which validators obtain ready-built blocks from specialised providers. In between sits a so-called relay, an intermediary service that is supposed to release block contents only once the validator has committed to the block. According to the indictment, in April 2023 the brothers deliberately placed bait transactions in the waiting area, which sandwich bots took. Through a vulnerability in the relay software, they allegedly saw the block contents early and rearranged the bots' transactions so that their stakes ended up with the brothers. By the prosecution's account, about twelve seconds were enough, and it put the haul at roughly $25 million.

Gizmodo describes the pattern vividly: the brothers squeezed the sandwich traders themselves. The victims were therefore not retail investors trying to swap a token, but operators of automated trading programs that in turn live off other people's orders.

From mistrial to acquittal: how the case has unfolded since 2024

The US Department of Justice unsealed the indictment in May 2024, and the brothers were arrested in Boston at the time. The trial before Judge Clarke ended in November 2025 without a verdict: the jury could not agree on a single count, and the court declared a mistrial.

Prosecutors then sought a second trial. The defence instead moved for acquittal under Rule 29 of the US Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. This rule allows the court to acquit defendants if the evidence is insufficient for a reasonable jury to convict. Clarke has now granted that motion.

Cointelegraph places the decision alongside the case of Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg. There, too, a judge in 2025 saw too little evidence of false statements. Both cases show how hard US prosecutors find it to capture trades over open protocols with the classic fraud statute.

Coin Center and validators: why the Ethereum community is relieved

The industry welcomed the acquittal. Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of the advocacy group Coin Center, spoke of “excellent news”, according to Cointelegraph. His concern was the “honest validator” theory on which the prosecution had built its case. Had it held, the state could in effect have used fraud law to dictate how validators on Ethereum must behave. Anyone taking part in an open network would then have to wonder whether prosecutors might later declare their conduct unlawful.

Line chart: bitcoin price in US dollars over 30 days
The bitcoin price in US dollars over the past 30 days, daily closing prices and current price. Source: CoinMarketCap, as of November 19, 2026, 8:52 pm CET

For operators of validators and block builders, the decision thus brings some legal certainty in the US. It remains open how courts will judge other MEV strategies, because the ruling covers only these facts and only the offences charged. That attacks on Ethereum's infrastructure are no theory was shown just this week by the theft of $6.45 million from a Safe multisig, which, however, worked differently.

The MEV ruling in Germany: what it means for DeFi users

Legally, a decision by a US district court binds no German authority and no German court. Nor does it change the mechanics behind the case: sandwich bots keep operating, and every publicly visible swap on a decentralised exchange can be their target. Anyone trading on Uniswap and similar platforms bears this risk alone, as there is no deposit protection or complaints office there.

Centralised trading venues are a different matter. There, orders run through an internal order book rather than through the blockchain's public waiting area, so a sandwich along the lines of this case is not possible. Which platforms are authorised under MiCA in Germany is shown in our comparison of regulated crypto exchanges, and the fees of the major providers are listed in our exchange comparison.

Sandwich protection: three settings against MEV bots on every swap

The bots in the Peraire-Bueno case were themselves the victims, but in normal operation they profit from ordinary trades. No court ruling protects you from them; the right setting before you click does:

  1. Keep slippage tight. Slippage tolerance is the maximum price deviation you accept on a swap. The wider it is, the more room a bot has. Most wallets allow a manual limit; which wallets handle this clearly is shown in our software wallet comparison.
  2. Use protected transmission. Some wallets and services do not send transactions to the public waiting area but directly to block builders. A sandwich bot then cannot see your order before it is in the block. Check your wallet's network settings to see whether it offers such an option.
  3. Trade large amounts via an order book. For larger trades, a licensed exchange with an order book is often the safer choice, because nobody can read your order on the network in advance. Our comparison of regulated crypto exchanges offers an overview.

The case against the brothers is closed with the acquittal. It does not answer the underlying question of how much exploitation of the rules is allowed in open networks. Many observers expect it to come up again with the next indictment.

(As of November 19, 2026. This article is not investment advice. Prices and fee structures change; check the terms with the provider before you buy.)

Partner links: some links on this page are partner links. If you become a customer through one of them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Selection, ratings and ranking are decided independently by our editorial team. Ethics and Independence · Ownership and Funding

Researched and compiled with AI. Before an article goes live, automated systems check the source links and hold back quotes and attributions without a verified source. Responsible editor: Dennis Weidner. The feature image was generated with AI. How we use AI

For later? Save this article and find it again in your profile.

Related articles

Which topics should we dive deeper into?

Select what genuinely interests you. Your picks feed directly into our editorial planning.

Crypto news that's actually worth your time.

Weekly. 60 seconds. Carefully curated by our editors: no hype, no promo flood, no spam.

Subscribe

More on this topic

View All

More from CryptoTicker