BSDEX vs Kraken Comparison

Editorial assessment, November 2026: We have downgraded BSDEX to 2.3 out of 5 and make no recommendation. The trading venue is regulated (Baden-Württembergische Wertpapierbörse GmbH and Boerse Stuttgart Digital Custody GmbH in the ESMA register, file dated 5 November 2026), but it offers too little: only 10 cryptocurrencies, no savings plan, SEPA transfer as the only payment method and two-factor authentication by SMS only. Buying with a market order costs 0.35 percent according to the BSDEX fee schedule (accessed 8 November 2026); the advertised 0.20 percent applies to maker orders only. MiCA-licensed exchanges with a broader offer are listed in our exchange comparison.

BSDEX is a regulated crypto trading venue of Börse Stuttgart. It is operated by Baden-Württembergische Wertpapierbörse GmbH, which notified BaFin of the venue under MiCA in July 2025. Custody is handled by Boerse Stuttgart Digital Custody GmbH under BaFin supervision, licensed under MiCA since January 2025 (according to the ESMA register, file of 30 October 2026). Euro balances are held at Solaris SE and Deutsche Bank and protected by statutory deposit insurance up to €100,000 per investor and bank. Withdrawals to your own wallet are free. That is solid, but compared with other platforms it is not enough for a good rating.

The offering is narrow: only 10 cryptocurrencies, no savings plan and SEPA bank transfer as the only payment method. BSDEX offers staking for ether and solana, at 2 to 8% a year according to its help centre, with insurance against slashing risk via Munich Re; unstaking takes 1 to 45 days depending on the blockchain. Buying with a market order costs 0.35 %; the advertised 0.20 % applies to maker orders only. Two-factor authentication works via SMS only, authenticator apps are not supported. Users are lukewarm too: the app scores 1.5 stars on Google Play and 3.2 on Trustpilot, with reports of login problems, repeated logouts and issues after updates.

Our verdict: BSDEX suits investors who only want to hold Bitcoin and a few large coins through German exchange infrastructure. If you are looking for a regulated platform with a wider selection or savings plans, Bitpanda or Coinbase are the better choice.

In short: Kraken is one of the oldest crypto exchanges in the world, active since 2011 and licensed under MiCA in the EEA. More than 600 coins, 490 of them directly against the euro, a regular proof of reserves and strong security features speak for the platform. The simple buy costs 1% plus spread; on the Kraken Pro order book you pay from 0.40% as a maker and 0.80% as a taker.

Is Kraken safe and licensed in the EU?

Yes, Kraken may serve customers across the EU. In the EEA, Kraken operates through Payward Europe Solutions Limited, based in Dublin, licensed under MiCA since 25 June 2025 and supervised by the Central Bank of Ireland. Through the EU passport the licence covers 30 EEA countries, including Germany, France and Spain (ESMA register, file of 30 October 2026). It covers custody, exchanging crypto for money and for other crypto, order execution and transfers, among other services. Kraken's parent Payward agreed on 14 October 2026 to buy Lithuania's Saldo Bank; closing is planned for 2027 and needs regulatory approval (our report on the deal).

Reserves and security: Kraken has its proof of reserves prepared regularly by auditors. The snapshot of 30 June 2026 shows coverage of 102.9% for Bitcoin, 100.5% for Ether, 100.6% for Solana and 102.3% for XRP, and 105% or more each for USDC and USDT. Kraken is certified to ISO/IEC 27001:2022, offers two-factor authentication with FIDO2 passkeys and a Global Settings Lock, and does not recover accounts by phone or SMS.

Account freezes and delistings: Between 17 and 24 August 2026, Kraken customers received almost 12,000 tiny deposits from wallets that analytics firms attribute to the sanctioned exchange HTX. Sanctions screening temporarily froze affected accounts; access has since been restored (our report on the dust attack). Kraken also removes tokens from trading regularly, most recently 13 tokens on 23 October 2026; withdrawal deadlines and steps are in our delisting report.

What you can do yourself: turn on a passkey or two-factor authentication and the Global Settings Lock, leave tiny deposits of unknown origin untouched and keep larger amounts on your own hardware wallet.

Who is Kraken for?

Kraken suits investors who want a long-established exchange with a wide choice of euro pairs, a savings plan and staking. Regular traders save with Kraken Pro. Since 26 October 2026, EEA customers with a derivatives account can also trade bitcoin and ether options there after an appropriateness assessment, provided by Cyprus-based Payward Europe Digital Solutions (CY) Limited under CySEC supervision. For simple euro trading, Bitvavo is cheaper, and Coinbase is an alternative with a listed parent company. All licensed providers are listed in our comparison of regulated crypto exchanges.