BSDEX vs Trade Republic Comparison
BSDEX and Trade Republic are practically level in our overall rating, 2.9 to 2.9 out of 5 points. On disclosed fees Trade Republic is cheaper: 0 % instead of 0.35 % trading fee. If you care most about usability and support, BSDEX has the better sub-scores, while Trade Republic leads on features.
| 0.35 % | Fees | 0 % |
| € 3.50 | Minimum cost per €1,000 | no order fee, cost in the spread |
| 10 | Cryptos | 50+ |
| SEPA Transfer | Payment Methods | SEPA Instant Transfer, SEPA Transfer, Credit Card |
| Custodian of cryptocurrencies (Boerse Stuttgart Digital Custody GmbH) has a BaFin license. | Regulation | Full banking licence from BaFin, crypto services notified under MiCA (Art. 60) |
Cost comparison
The basis is a Bitcoin purchase worth €1,000, calculated from the disclosed trading fee. A price markup in the spread is not included, because most providers do not publish it.
| € 3.50 | Minimum cost per €1,000 | no order fee, cost in the spread |
| 0.35 % | Fees | 0 % |
| € 0 | Wallet transfer | € 0 |
| Yes | Cost transparency | Limited |
| € 10 | Minimum Amount | € 1 |
| SEPA Transfer | Payment Methods | SEPA Instant Transfer, SEPA Transfer, Credit Card |
Not enough reviews available.
Trade Republic charges no order commission for crypto trading. Each single order carries a flat fee of EUR 1, while savings plans run without it. Every purchase and sale also includes the spread, the gap between buy and sell price, which is built into the quoted price.
| Transaction | Cost at Trade Republic |
|---|---|
| Buying or selling a cryptocurrency (single order) | EUR 1 flat fee per order, no order commission, plus the spread |
| Crypto savings plan from EUR 1 | no flat fee, only the spread |
| Custody of your coins | free, most of it held in cold wallets at BitGo Europe GmbH |
| Sending to and receiving from external wallets | no Trade Republic fee, only the blockchain's network costs |
| Staking, including SOL, ETH and DOT | no additional fee, the app shows the net yield |
| Paying with crypto via the card | only the spread; 2% Crypto Saveback on up to EUR 1,500 card spending per month if at least EUR 50 goes into savings plans each month |
| Card: monthly fee and withdrawals | free, withdrawals under EUR 100 cost EUR 1 |
How to save: If you buy regularly, use the savings plan, since the EUR 1 flat fee does not apply there. For single orders, larger amounts pay off: on EUR 50 the flat fee is 2%, on EUR 1,000 only 0.1%. We compare exchanges with maker and taker fees in our crypto exchange comparison.
As of 22 October 2026 according to Trade Republic's crypto page and price overview and its help article on crypto fees (German price list).
Pros & Cons
- All 10 cryptocurrencies trade directly against the euro
- Trading and custody under BaFin supervision, custody with Boerse Stuttgart Digital Custody GmbH
- Wallet transfer always free
- The advertised 0.20 % applies to maker orders only. Buying with a market order, which is the normal case, costs 0.35 %, that is 75 % more.
- Only 10 cryptocurrencies, far fewer than at large exchanges
- No savings plan and no staking available
- Only SEPA bank transfer as a payment method
- Two-factor authentication via SMS only, no authenticator app
- Weak app ratings: 1.5 stars on Google Play
- MiCA authorisation from BaFin, listed in the French AMF's CASP register as “Licensed MICA” with Germany as the licensing country
- Savings plans for crypto, stocks and ETFs from €1
- Crypto transfers to and from external wallets with no transaction fee charged by Trade Republic
- Staking available, according to the provider for SOL, ETH and DOT among others, at no extra charge
- 2 % Crypto Saveback on card payments up to €1,500 per month
- No order commission on crypto: EUR 1 flat fee per single order, savings plans without it, plus the spread
- 50 cryptocurrencies tradable alongside stocks and ETFs
- Deposits via SEPA, SEPA instant transfer and credit card
- Trade Republic's own help pages contradict its product page: on 22 October 2026 they still stated that sending and receiving crypto was not possible
- Cost transparency on crypto spreads has room for improvement, according to users
- SMS-based two-factor authentication; stronger methods would be welcome
Score Comparison
User Experiences
AI AnalysisUser reports on BSDEX overall paint a mixed picture: the clear layout, easy usability and low fees are mentioned frequently, while technical hurdles with login and app usage are also noted in the reviews.
According to the evaluated user data, Trade Republic is especially appreciated for its intuitive and clear app. At the same time, users report room for improvement in support, while fees and individual aspects of the app are perceived in mixed ways according to reviews.
This analysis is based on 578 user reviews evaluated by AI from the Apple App Store, Trustpilot, and Google Play Store. The total number of reviews on the respective platforms may be higher — the platform ratings shown (star ratings) refer to all reviews available there. The reviews presented reflect user experiences and do not represent the site operator's own assessment. All information is provided without guarantee. As of: March 2026. This comparison does not constitute investment advice.
Features
| not available | Savings plan | available |
| not available | Staking | not available |
| available | Wallet transfer | not available |
| available | Cost transparency | not specified |
| available | 2FA security | not specified |
| available | SEPA bank transfer | not specified |
| not available | Credit card | available |
| not available | Minimum amount | not specified |
| available | Mobile app (iOS/Android) | available |
| available | Web platform | available |
| not specified | BaFin regulation | available |
| not specified | Stocks & ETFs | available |
| not specified | SEPA instant transfer | available |
- Regulated trading venue of Börse Stuttgart
- Free wallet withdrawals
- Only 10 coins, no savings plan, no staking
- Market orders 0.35 %, maker 0.20 %
- Neobroker for crypto, stocks, ETFs, and derivatives from a single source
- Savings plans from €1 for long-term wealth building
- BaFin-regulated with a German bank account
- Over 50 tradable cryptocurrencies
The five areas head to head
AI AnalysisFees & Costs
Many users respond positively to the fees and costs. Low fees are highlighted several times in the reviews. Overall, the cost structure is perceived positively from the user perspective.
When it comes to fees and costs, user opinions are mixed. Some users describe Trade Republic as inexpensive, while according to reviews, higher fees are also occasionally criticized.
Usability & User Experience
Users often describe BSDEX as clear and easy to understand, and the intuitive app is also mentioned positively in reviews. At the same time, users report technical hurdles when using the platform, for example when logins are not possible, users have to log in again repeatedly, or the app occasionally freezes.
Users particularly appreciate Trade Republic for its intuitive, clear, and easy-to-use app. According to reviews, the application is often described as beginner-friendly, which makes getting started easier. However, the app is also occasionally described as somewhat unclear.
Features & Offering
Regarding features and the offering, the user data shows a rather reserved picture. Users mainly want more coins and more altcoins; a savings plan, a profit-and-loss display and a dark mode are also mentioned occasionally. According to reviews, a chart display is also sometimes requested.
Users repeatedly wish for availability in Switzerland, an iPad version, and a CSV export. According to reviews, a simpler tax overview and the option for automatic dividend reinvestment are also mentioned occasionally. Wishes are also expressed in the available user data regarding the search function and stop-limit orders.
Stability & Security
Regarding stability and reliability, users report in part positively about dependable everyday use. At the same time, reviews mention update problems, app startup difficulties, FaceID errors and repeated logouts. The fact that withdrawals are not possible is also occasionally mentioned in the user data.
Users report mixed experiences regarding stability and reliability. It is occasionally mentioned that the app crashes, while others describe the app as easy to use in everyday life.
Customer Support
The support is described by users in several reviews as fast, helpful and competent. Users particularly praise the prompt assistance in direct contact. In individual cases, users would like even more support for specific issues.
When it comes to support, many users report room for improvement. According to reviews, it is often mentioned that customer service is difficult to reach or that responses take a while to arrive. In direct contact in particular, users therefore rate support critically.
Details
| Baden-Württembergische Wertpapierbörse GmbH | Company | Trade Republic Bank GmbH |
| 2019 | Founded | 2015 |
| Custodian of cryptocurrencies (Boerse Stuttgart Digital Custody GmbH) has a BaFin license. | Regulation | Full banking licence from BaFin, crypto services notified under MiCA (Art. 60) |
| € 10 | Minimum Amount | € 1 |
| VideoIdent | KYC | Video-ID |
Verdict
Both providers are practically level in our overall rating (2.9 to 2.9).
Neither provider reaches 4.0 out of 5 in our rating, so we do not give an unreserved recommendation here.
BSDEX is a regulated crypto trading venue of Börse Stuttgart. Custody is handled by Boerse Stuttgart Digital Custody GmbH under BaFin supervision, and withdrawals to your own wallet are free. That is solid, but compared with other platforms it is not enough for a good rating.
The offering is narrow: only 10 cryptocurrencies, no savings plan, no staking and SEPA bank transfer as the only payment method. Buying with a market order costs 0.35 %; the advertised 0.20 % applies to maker orders only. Two-factor authentication works via SMS only, authenticator apps are not supported. Users are lukewarm too: the app scores 1.5 stars on Google Play and 3.2 on Trustpilot, with reports of login problems, repeated logouts and issues after updates.
Our verdict: BSDEX suits investors who only want to hold Bitcoin and a few large coins through German exchange infrastructure. If you are looking for a regulated platform with a wider selection, savings plans or staking, Bitpanda or Coinbase are the better choice.
Trade Republic is considered one of the best-known neobrokers in the DACH region and is used by many users as an entry point into the world of cryptocurrencies. Trade Republic is a bank supervised by BaFin and, in addition to 50 cryptocurrencies, also offers stocks, ETFs, and derivatives from a single source. Users appreciate that Trade Republic charges no order commission; each single order costs a flat EUR 1, savings plans run without it, and the remaining costs arise through the spread, whose transparency is occasionally rated as room for improvement.
Particularly appreciated are the savings plans from €1, which make it easy to get started with regular crypto investing. For investors who want to manage crypto, stocks, and ETFs in a single app, Trade Republic is considered one of the most accessible solutions on the German market. The app is described as intuitive and clearly geared toward beginners and occasional investors.
The Crypto Wallet lets you send cryptocurrencies to external wallets and receive them from there, according to Trade Republic without any transaction fees of its own. The SMS-based 2FA security is also considered room for improvement. Trade Republic is therefore especially suitable for investors looking for a regulated, uncomplicated way to access cryptocurrencies as part of a broad securities offering and who want to be able to move their coins to a wallet of their own.