CoinTracker vs Koinly Comparison

CoinTracker
CoinTracker
4.7of 5
Go to CoinTracker
vs
Koinly
Koinly
4.8of 5
Go to Koinly

Cost comparison

CoinTracker

CoinTracker charges an annual subscription. The price depends on the number of transactions in the current tax year, and the tax forms for every past year are included in the plan. Spam and dust do not count towards the limit.

PlanTransactions in the tax yearPrice per year
Freetracking and tax summary only$0
Base100$59
Base+250$99
Prime1,000$199
Prime+2,500$299
Ultra10,000$499
Ultra+25,000$999
Higher volumesover 25,000from $1,999
Full Serviceup to 300,000from $3,499

Moving up to a higher plan only costs the difference. The subscription renews automatically each year, and auto-renewal can be switched off at any time. CoinTracker refunds the price within 30 days of purchase as long as no tax forms have been downloaded. Partner promotions apply to the first year only. The pricing page lists US dollars, and checkout is possible in your local currency. Prices as of 1 November 2026 according to CoinTracker's pricing page.

Koinly

Not enough reviews available.

Pros & Cons

CoinTracker
CoinTracker
Pros
  • Supports over 500 exchanges and wallets
  • Automatic categorization of smart contracts and NFTs integrated
  • SOC 1- and SOC 2-certified security standards
  • Mobile app for iOS and Android as well as web version available
  • For Germany: an Anlage SO report, a CSV file for WISO and a tax report for your tax adviser, with the one-year holding period shown
  • Free portfolio tracking with a tax summary; a paid annual plan includes the tax forms for every past year, and the price depends only on the current tax year's transactions
Cons
  • Pricing structure at high transaction volumes has room for improvement: $59 to $999 a year depending on transactions in the tax year, higher volumes from $1,999, Full Service from $3,499
  • Focus on the US market: the plans highlight US forms such as Form 8949 and the TurboTax integration, and the Germany page is only available in English
  • Annual subscription that renews automatically; setting a cost basis method per wallet and year requires the Ultra plan at $499
CoinTracker Reviews
Koinly
Koinly
Pros
  • Supports over 900 exchanges, wallets and blockchains, plus more than 7,200 DeFi protocols
  • Simple, beginner-friendly setup is appreciated
  • Integrated DeFi, staking, and mining tracking
  • Free plan: import up to 10,000 transactions, portfolio tracking and a capital gains preview without any payment obligation
  • Support for FIFO, LIFO, HIFO, and ACB as tax methods
  • No subscription: you only pay for the tax report per tax year, refundable within 7 days as long as no report has been generated
Cons
  • Audit support is currently not available and is occasionally criticized
  • Payment per tax year: €49 for up to 100 transactions, €99 for 1,000, €199 for 3,000; catching up on several years means paying for each year separately
  • German localization is patchy: parts of the German pricing page are only in English
  • The iOS app is so far only available as a TestFlight beta, not in the App Store
Koinly Reviews

Score Comparison

4.6Usability4.6
4.6Features4.4
4.2Fees4.0
4.1Stability4.3
4.3Support3.7

User Experiences

AI Analysis
4.7
App Store
—
4.4
Google Play
—
4.6
Trustpilot
—
CoinTracker
CoinTracker

According to user feedback, CoinTracker is generally described rather positively overall. Users especially appreciate that many pieces of information are bundled in one place and that the application supports tax documentation. However, some users occasionally report login issues, high costs, and individual service experiences.

Koinly
Koinly

Not enough reviews available.

Provider details (fees, licences, pros and cons) editorially reviewed: November 2026. This analysis is based on 413 AI-evaluated user reviews from the Apple App Store, Trustpilot, Google Play Store. The total number of reviews on the respective platforms may be higher, the platform ratings (star ratings) shown refer to all reviews available there. The ratings displayed reflect users' experiences and do not represent the website operator's own assessment. All information is provided without guarantee. As of: April 2026. This comparison does not constitute investment advice.

Features

CoinTrackerKoinly
availableDeFi supportavailable
not availableTax advisor exportnot available
availableFIFO methodavailable
availableLIFO methodavailable
not availableAPI accessnot available
not availableMobile appnot available
not availableFree plannot available
availableNFT trackingavailable
availableStaking trackingavailable
not availableAudit supportnot available
CoinTracker
CoinTrackerHighlights
  • Real-time API and automatic wallet monitoring
  • SOC 1 and SOC 2 certification for data security
  • Tax professional portal and full-service options for comprehensive support
  • Tiered plans from 100 to 300,000 transactions per tax year
  • Anlage SO report and WISO CSV file for Germany
Koinly
KoinlyHighlights
  • Android app on Google Play with more than 100,000 downloads
  • Support for over 20 countries with country-specific tax reports
  • Live chat and email support for quick help
  • Automatic import via API and wallet addresses

The five areas head to head

AI Analysis

Fees & Costs

CoinTracker
CoinTracker

When it comes to fees and costs, users report criticism comparatively often. According to user reviews, prices and fees are occasionally described as high. Overall, users tend to view this area rather critically.

Koinly
Koinly

Importing is free: up to 10,000 transactions can be loaded, wallets and exchanges connected without limit, and capital gains previewed. Payment is only due when downloading the finished tax report, charged per tax year: €49 for 100 transactions, €99 for 1,000 and €199 for 3,000. For larger volumes there is the Pro plan, to which further transactions can be added in the app in packs of 1,000; the pricing page does not show a price for it. There is no subscription: anyone needing a report once a year pays for that year only, and as long as no report has been generated, Koinly refunds the purchase within 7 days. As of 1 November 2026, prices as shown on Koinly's pricing page when accessed from Germany.

Usability & User Experience

CoinTracker
CoinTracker

According to reviews, CoinTracker is described by many users as intuitive and very easy to use. Users especially appreciate that everything comes together in one view and that wallets can be connected easily. However, some users occasionally report login problems and an app that is somewhat laggy at times.

Koinly
Koinly

Setup is regarded as the most approachable entry point among tax tools: exchanges connect by API or CSV and categorisation runs largely automatically. Users with heavy DeFi activity still need to reconcile manually. As of August 2026.

Features & Offering

CoinTracker
CoinTracker

Users appreciate that CoinTracker bundles many crypto data points in one place and supports tax documents. According to reviews, features around the overview and tax documentation are frequently praised. At the same time, users say they would like live updates, widgets, a crypto search function, and support for staking transactions on Coinbase.

Koinly
Koinly

More than 900 exchanges, wallets and blockchains are connected, plus over 7,200 DeFi protocols. Country-specific tax reports are available for the US, UK, Canada, Australia, Germany and around 20 further jurisdictions, which matters because the output has to match the local filing format. Portfolio tracking and an Android app round this out; for iOS there is so far a TestFlight beta. As of 1 November 2026.

Stability & Security

CoinTracker
CoinTracker

Regarding stability and reliability, users occasionally report login issues, a broken time filter, or an app that responds slowly. Overall, the reviews suggest a mixed picture.

Koinly
Koinly

Not enough reviews available.

Customer Support

CoinTracker
CoinTracker

User data presents a mixed picture of support. Some users explicitly praise the support, while others report, according to reviews, that tickets received no response or that they were unable to reach support at all. Accordingly, users tend to describe the service area rather critically overall.

Koinly
Koinly

Not enough reviews available.

Details

Verdict

Both providers are practically level in our overall rating (4.7 to 4.8).

CoinTrackerOur Opinion

CoinTracker is regarded as one of the most user-friendly crypto tax tools on the market. With more than 500 integrations for exchanges and wallets, as well as automatic categorization of smart contracts and NFTs, the platform is aimed at users who value a setup that is as smooth as possible. The SOC 1 and SOC 2 certification is viewed positively as a quality feature in data security, an aspect that is particularly relevant when transferring sensitive tax data.

The availability of a mobile app for iOS and Android, along with the real-time API and automatic wallet monitoring, sets CoinTracker apart from many competitors. Tax reports can be exported in CSV and PDF format, as well as directly for TurboTax and H&R Block. For Germany there is a dedicated section with an Anlage SO report, a CSV file for WISO and a tax report for your tax adviser; it shows private disposals, the status of the one-year holding period and income such as staking rewards. Professional users have access to a tax professional portal and full-service options that enable comprehensive support. Supported methods are FIFO plus HIFO and LIFO as specific identification; HIFO is the default, and for Germany CoinTracker lists FIFO as the method, which can be selected in the settings.

According to the pricing page, plans cost $59 to $999 a year, tiered by the transactions of the current tax year; for larger histories they start at $1,999, and Full Service starts at $3,499. A plan includes the tax forms for every past year and renews automatically each year. The pricing structure is occasionally described as having room for improvement at higher transaction volumes. The platform still focuses on the US market, and the Germany page and the plan descriptions are in English. CoinTracker is therefore seen as particularly suitable for internationally oriented users and those focused on the US tax environment, although German investors now have their own route to a tax return through the Anlage SO report.

KoinlyOur Opinion

Koinly is especially valued for its beginner-friendly interface and broad coverage of more than 900 exchanges, wallets and blockchains. The setup is considered straightforward, which is particularly helpful for users who are dealing with the tax reporting of cryptocurrencies for the first time. With support for FIFO, LIFO, HIFO, and ACB as tax methods, Koinly covers the calculation methods commonly used in Germany. DeFi, staking, and mining transactions are also automatically recognized and categorized.

The free portfolio tracking makes it easy to get started without having to pay right away: up to 10,000 transactions can be imported and capital gains previewed. The Android app complements the web version, while for the iPhone there is so far only a TestFlight beta. Payment is due only for the tax report, per tax year €49 for up to 100 transactions, €99 for 1,000 and €199 for 3,000; that is moderate in market comparison, although the costs at high transaction volumes are seen as room for improvement. Koinly offers country-specific tax reports for more than 20 countries, underlining its international usability.

For Germany, Koinly produces a dedicated tax report that is filed with the tax return via ELSTER, although parts of the German pricing page are only in English. Audit support is also currently missing, which may be relevant for users with more complex tax requirements. Overall, Koinly is seen as a solid choice for beginners and users with medium transaction volumes who are looking for an intuitive tool with broad exchange coverage and mobile access.