Crypto Exchanges Unite: Coinbase, Kraken, etc create a rating system for digital tokens
Major crypto exchanges in the US have come together in order to decide whether an ICO is a security or not. And the most interesting fact is that this was not done in response to a court ruling or due […]

Which topics should we dive deeper into?
Select what genuinely interests you. Your picks feed directly into our editorial planning.
Crypto news that's actually worth your time.
Weekly. 60 seconds. Carefully curated by our editors: no hype, no promo flood, no spam.
Major crypto exchanges in the US have come together in order to decide whether an ICO is a security or not. And the most interesting fact is that this was not done in response to a court ruling or due to some directive by the SEC forcing them to do so. This is exactly what makes the move an interesting one, a voluntary action. The move, for the most part, is positive. It gives investors and buyers of tokens more information in a condensed manner to make a proper decision. But it leaves many questions unanswered.
CRC rating
The founding members of the council include Coinbase, Kraken, Circle, Bittrex, and Grayscale. The council evaluation of coins is a point-based system with the score reflecting the confidence they have that given crypto is a security or not. The analytical framework is based on relevant laws and statements from the SEC staff relating to digital assets, including the SEC’s “Framework for Investment Contract of Digital Assets”. This is what those scores mean: A score of 1 means the Council’s analysis found that an asset has few or no characteristics consistent with treatment as security. A score of 5 means the Council’s analysis found that an asset has many characteristics strongly consistent with treatment as security. And finally, scores in between reflect the relative strength and presence of characteristics relevant to the Council’s framework. The main motivation of the rating is to make the process of analyzing a token easier because such an analysis is difficult and expensive to operationalize consistently, may involve judgment calls, and can lead to disagreement even among legal experts.
Reliable rating?
These exchanges have no experience in such matters and more than that even the SEC is not sure how to deal with ICOs. Even though the SEC has recently released the ‘Framework for “Investment Contract” Analysis of Digital Assets’, it is vague and opens room for broad interpretation. Another concern is the conflict of interest as it leaves room for the crypto exchanges to decide whether an ICO is a security or not. Without proper oversight, such a power can be misused in a number of ways. Another issue is the validity of these rating as in the FAQ section of CRC it is written, “The framework is the Council’s attempt to provide a consistent analysis which the members find useful but it is not legal advice and does not reflect the opinion of any member or outside counsel of whether any given asset is a security”.
The whole thing seems like a huge waste of time given that the ratings don’t mean much, even from the standpoint of the council. But it is a clever way of making sure that the exchanges are not caught in the middle of crossfire between SEC and any one of these coins, and even though the council has made it clear that their rating is ”not legal advice and does not reflect the opinion of any member”, it doesn’t prevent those members from acting on those ratings. There have been a lot of talks about self-regulation for a long time in the crypto world, and this seems like the best example where stakeholders come together to bring a structure. Unfortunately what this means for crypto enthusiasts is that it will not be the anarchist world they dreamt of. As they say “order from chaos” seems to be a fit for this situation.
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Steemit, and join our Telegram channel for the latest blockchain and cryptocurrency news
Compare MiCA-regulated crypto exchanges
Find the right exchange for your tokensPartner links: some links on this page are partner links. If you become a customer through one of them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Selection, ratings and ranking are decided independently by our editorial team. Ethics and Independence · Ownership and Funding
For later? Save this article and find it again in your profile.
Related articles
Which topics should we dive deeper into?
Select what genuinely interests you. Your picks feed directly into our editorial planning.
Crypto news that's actually worth your time.
Weekly. 60 seconds. Carefully curated by our editors: no hype, no promo flood, no spam.
March 15, 2024 7:37 PM

Non Fungible Conference is “so back” in Lisbon: 28-30 May
The Non Fungible Conference (NFC), leading conference on Web3 and NFT, returns to Lisbon on May 28th, 29th, and 30th, 2024.
March 7, 2024 6:00 AM

The Potential Wormhole Airdrop Guide: How to Check for the $W Token Airdrop?
The W token is designed to serve as a governance asset. Let's take a look at this Wormhole airdrop guide in more detail.
March 5, 2024 6:28 AM

Shib Halts Named Token Transfers: Shiba Inu Price To Skyrocket Further?
Will SHIB price rise further? Let's take a look at this SHIB price article in more detail. The initial SHIB Name Service will be distributed.
February 29, 2024 7:31 AM

Unfulfilled Promises and Disappointments: A Critical Review of the World of Women (WoW) Gala 2024 Event
While World of Woman claims to champion the representation of women, the reality behind the scenes paints a different picture.
February 28, 2024 1:24 PM

The Upcoming Crypto Super Thursday 2024: A Day of Launches, Rewards, and Excitement
As the crypto world gears up for what enthusiasts are dubbing "Crypto Super Thursday," anticipation is at an all-time high
February 27, 2024 7:59 AM

Top 5 Best NFT Marketplaces for 2024
Explore the top 5 NFT marketplaces for 2024! From Blur's advanced tools to OpenSea's variety, find the perfect platform for your NFT.
February 19, 2024 4:41 PM

Web3 Security Essentials: A Guide to Web3 Security
This comprehensive guide delves into the aspects of Web3 security, offering in-depth insights for safely navigating this world.
February 19, 2024 4:24 PM

5 Solana Meme Coins From 2024 Revisited: BONK, APING, KING, DRAGON and KIN
In February 2024 these five Solana meme coins were on every watchlist. What became of BONK, APING, KING, DRAGON and KIN by September 2026.
February 18, 2024 11:00 PM

OKX Continues to Impress with its Transparent Growth
Dive into OKX's latest move in enhancing transparency with their 11th PoR report, showcasing a notable growth in their crypto assets. Discover how OKX is setting new standards in the crypto industry.
February 18, 2024 11:00 PM

Grapes (GRAPE)Token: Live Trading on Bitget Now!
Grapes is poised to extend its influence beyond gaming, venturing. The new big thing: GRAPE Goes Live on Bitget
February 18, 2024 5:22 PM

BIG AIRDROP: PIXEL Tokens Airdrop To RON Stakers
The snapshot for eligibility was taken on February 8th at 10:00 am. Let's take a look at this PIXEL airdrop
February 14, 2024 2:45 PM

Massive Starknet Airdrop: 700M STRK Tokens to 1.3m Users! How to be eligible for STRK Airdrop?
On February 20, 2024, the Starknet Foundation team is set to distribute Starknet airdrop. Let's take a look at this initiative.
February 9, 2024 7:27 AM

Ethereum ERC-404 Token PANDORA Grew by Massive 1000% – What is “ERC-404”? Everything You Need To Know
There's a hot new thing in the crypto world called the ERC-404 token standard. Let's take a look at What is ERC-404 standard in more detail.
January 27, 2024 6:18 AM

Another Day, Another Airdrop: What’s The New Hype Behind The AltLayer Airdrop?
At the time of writing this, the market cap of ALT token is almost $400M. Let's take a look at this AltLayer Airdrop news in more detail.
January 12, 2024 9:32 AM

Ethereum Name Service Price Explodes: Why the Price is Rising and How High Can the ENS Price Go?
The ENS price too surged by more than 158% in the last 30 days. Let's take a look at this ENS price prediction article in more detail.
January 8, 2024 5:29 AM

INTO THE BLUE by Manta Network: The Comprehensive $MANTA Airdrop Guide
Manta Network has officially announced the commencement of the "Into the Blue" airdrop. Let's take a look at this MANTA airdrop guide
December 31, 2023 8:11 AM

Ultimate Guide To Rainbow Wallet Airdrop
Rainbow has unveiled its Rainbow Points rewards initiative. This article is all about the simple guide on Rainbow wallet airdrop
December 29, 2023 8:21 AM

Ultimate Guide to CARV Protocol Airdrop: Earn SOUL, Receive Airdrop
The Carv Protocol is set to introduce the initiation of the $SOUL Drop Campaign. This article is all about the CARV Protocol airdrop.
December 26, 2023 6:44 AM

Solana Price Prediction for 2024: Will the SOL Price Rise to $2,000?
Will the SOL price rise to $2000 in 2024? Let's take a look at this Solana price prediction article in more detail.
December 25, 2023 7:58 AM

How to buy Solana(SOL) on Bitget? Easy Guide
This article provides insights into the opportune moment to buy Solana and outlines the process of how to buy Solana (SOL) on Bitget
December 20, 2023 1:30 PM

Did you miss Solana Airdrop? Catch Up with Injective Airdrop Big Season
If you missed Solana's airdrop then dive into the excitement with Injective airdrop season! Let's take a look at this.
November 30, 2023 11:34 PM

Grapes NFT Project: What is it and what is Grapecoin?
Amidst the decline of good NFT projects, the Grapes NFT emerges as a beacon of innovation and potential. What is it and what is Grapecoin?
November 19, 2023 2:11 PM

Why did Yearn Finance Crash? YFI Price tumbles around -45%
Yearn finance YFI token experienced a crash, plunging over 43%. Why did Yearn Finance crash? Was it a rug-pull or a price adjustment?
October 23, 2023 3:07 AM

The Reddit MOON Token Controversy: Inside Trading Allegations Surface
"Reddit MOON Token Controversy" unraveled: Inside trading claims shake the crypto world after Reddit's community points program halt.
September 15, 2023 1:41 AM

Review: Cryptoticker.io’s Unforgettable Journey at TOKEN 2049, Singapore
Dive into Cryptoticker.io's exhilarating experience at TOKEN 2049 in Singapore. From networking drinks to enlightening talks, it was a journey to remember at the Sands Expo & Convention Centre.
More from CryptoTicker
